Bridging British Education Virtual Academy 伦桥国际教育
Debating Skills Practice - Third Speaker Role 辩论技巧练习 - 第三发言人角色
1. Course Basic Information 1. 课程基本信息
Teaching Focus 教学重点
Understanding and executing the role of the Third Speaker in a debate, followed by a full debate practice on the motion: 'Professional athletes are overpaid.'
理解并执行辩论中第三发言人的角色，随后就“职业运动员收入过高”的动议进行全面辩论练习。
Teaching Objectives 教学目标
-
Students will be able to define the responsibilities of a Third Speaker (rebuttal, summarizing team's case, no new arguments). 学生将能够定义第三发言人的职责（反驳、总结团队论点、不引入新论点）。
-
Students will practice applying third speaker skills within a formal debate setting. 学生将在正式辩论环境中练习应用第三发言人的技巧。
-
Students will argue for or against the motion: 'Professional athletes are overpaid,' utilizing debate structure. 学生将就“职业运动员收入过高”的动议进行正反方辩论，并运用辩论结构。
2. Course Content Overview 2. 课程内容概览
Main Teaching Activities and Time Allocation 主要教学活动和时间分配
Student Check-in and Homework Discussion: Teacher checks in with Clara about homework load. Welcomes guest student Neil (former summer course participant).
学生问候与作业讨论： 教师与Clara核查作业情况。欢迎嘉宾学生Neil（夏季课程学员）。
Third Speaker Role Analysis: Detailed explanation of the Third Speaker's role: listen, make notes, rebut, summarize team's points, and strictly avoid introducing new material. Students provide input on required skills (listening, summarizing).
第三发言人角色分析： 详细解释第三发言人的角色：倾听、做笔记、反驳、总结团队论点，并严格避免引入新材料。学生对所需技能（倾听、总结）提供反馈。
Video Analysis and Discussion: Watched a video example of a Third Speaker. Discussed what made the performance strong (structure, technique, opinion integration). Welcomed Mason.
视频分析与讨论： 观看了第三发言人的示例视频。讨论了表演的优点（结构、技巧、观点整合）。欢迎了Mason。
Debate Setup and Preparation: Introduced the debate motion: 'Professional athletes are overpaid.' Assigned teams (Boys Agree vs. Girls Disagree). Welcomed Renee to the disagree team. Students prepared arguments for 10 minutes.
辩论设置与准备： 介绍了辩论动议：“职业运动员收入过高”。分配队伍（男生赞成 vs. 女生反对）。欢迎Renee加入反方。学生进行10分钟的论点准备。
Formal Debate Round: The debate commenced with 3-minute speaking slots for each speaker (Mason, Chloe, Neil, Zoe, Clive (Teacher substitute for 3rd speaker), Renee). Teacher acted as chair/adjudicator.
正式辩论环节： 辩论开始，每位发言人（Mason, Chloe, Neil, Zoe, Clive (教师代班第三发言人), Renee）有3分钟发言时间。教师担任主席/裁判。
Verdict and Feedback: Teacher adjudicated the debate, awarding the win to the Negative Team (Chloe, Zoe, Renee) due to strong breakdown and clear structuring. Specific feedback given to all participants.
裁决与反馈： 教师裁决了辩论，将胜利判给反方（Chloe, Zoe, Renee），因其出色的论点拆解和清晰的结构。对所有参与者提供了具体反馈。
Language Knowledge and Skills 语言知识与技能
rebut, adjudicator, affirmative, negative, affirmative team, negative team, motion, sophisticated, cooped up, Wikipedia, copy and paste, contradict, reiterate, bonuses, payout, hype, half-time
反驳, 裁判, 正方, 反方, 正方团队, 反方团队, 动议, 老练的/复杂的, 关在里面, 维基百科, 复制粘贴, 反驳/抵触, 重申, 奖金, 支付/分红, 炒作/过分宣传, 中场休息
Third Speaker Strategy (No New Material), Fair Pay in Sports, Salary Comparison (Athletes vs. Essential Workers), The Value of Time/Sacrifice in Professional Sports.
第三发言人策略（无新材料）, 体育中的公平薪酬, 薪资对比（运动员 vs. 必要职业人员）, 职业体育中时间/牺牲的价值。
Active listening for rebuttal, summarizing complex arguments, formal debate structure, persuasive speaking under pressure.
为反驳而进行的主动倾听, 总结复杂论点, 正式辩论结构, 压力下的说服性表达。
Teaching Resources and Materials 教学资源与材料
-
Example video of a strong Third Speaker speech. 一个优秀第三发言人演讲的示例视频。
-
Debate Motion Card: 'Professional athletes are overpaid.' 辩论动议卡：“职业运动员收入过高。”
3. Student Performance Assessment (Clara, Zoe, Neil (Guest), Mason, Renee (Guest)) 3. 学生表现评估 (Clara, Zoe, Neil (Guest), Mason, Renee (Guest))
Participation and Activeness 参与度和积极性
-
All participating students (Clara, Zoe, Mason, Neil, Renee) engaged actively in both the theoretical discussion and the full debate simulation. 所有参与学生（Clara, Zoe, Mason, Neil, Renee）都积极参与了理论讨论和完整的辩论模拟。
Language Comprehension and Mastery 语言理解和掌握
-
Students demonstrated a strong understanding of the Third Speaker's constraints, especially Renee who successfully applied the role immediately upon arrival. 学生们表现出对第三发言人限制的深刻理解，特别是Renee，她在加入后立即成功地扮演了该角色。
-
Debaters successfully integrated specific points from previous speakers into their arguments and rebuttals. 辩论者成功地将先前发言人的特定论点融入到他们的论证和反驳中。
Language Output Ability 语言输出能力
Oral: 口语：
-
Neil showed good pacing and used effective examples in his arguments. Neil在论证中展示了良好的语速控制和有效的例子使用。
-
Chloe and Zoe provided structured opening and second speaker arguments, using clear enumeration. Chloe和Zoe提供了结构清晰的开篇和第二发言论点，使用了明确的编号列举。
Written: 书面：
N/A (Focus was on oral debate skills)
不适用（重点在于口语辩论技巧）
Student's Strengths 学生的优势
-
Renee's quick adaptation to the Third Speaker role, summarizing and rebutting effectively with little preparation. Renee快速适应第三发言人角色，准备时间短却能有效总结和反驳。
-
Chloe's strong structuring of the initial arguments, especially focusing on less popular sports (Netball) for contrast. Chloe的论点结构清晰，特别是关注了不太受欢迎的运动（如无板篮球）以形成对比。
-
Mason and Neil's collaborative effort in team preparation and providing concrete examples (e.g., Messi). Mason和Neil在团队准备中展现了良好的协作，并提供了具体的例子（如梅西）。
Areas for Improvement 需要改进的方面
-
Clara's initial participation seemed lower before the main debate, though she settled in during the preparation phase. Clara在主要辩论开始前的初期参与度略低，但在准备阶段进入了状态。
-
Some students occasionally spoke too quietly (Renee, at times), making it hard for the adjudicator to hear clearly. 部分学生发言音量有时过低（如Renee），导致裁判难以清晰听取。
-
Mason needs further practice in clearly distinguishing between supporting points and rebuttals, as his initial argument structure was slightly unclear. Mason需要进一步练习清晰地区分支持论点和反驳，因为他最初的论点结构略显模糊。
4. Teaching Reflection 4. 教学反思
Effectiveness of Teaching Methods 教学方法的有效性
-
The explicit teaching of the Third Speaker role followed immediately by a practical application debate was highly effective for concept reinforcement. 明确教授第三发言人角色后紧接着进行实际辩论应用，对于巩固概念非常有效。
-
The adjudicator role played by the teacher successfully managed time constraints and provided balanced, constructive feedback. 教师扮演的裁判角色成功地管理了时间限制，并提供了平衡且建设性的反馈。
Teaching Pace and Time Management 教学节奏和时间管理
-
The preparation phase pace was energetic, allowing students to collaborate effectively before the timed debate segments. 准备阶段的节奏充满活力，使学生能够在计时辩论环节前进行有效的协作。
-
Strict adherence to the 3-minute time limit for speakers ensured the debate concluded efficiently, though some speakers seemed rushed at the end. 严格遵守发言人3分钟的时限确保了辩论的有效结束，尽管一些发言人在结尾时略显仓促。
Classroom Interaction and Atmosphere 课堂互动和氛围
The atmosphere was engaging, supportive, and competitive, particularly during the debate setup when students were clearly motivated to win for their teams.
课堂气氛既投入、支持性强，又具有竞争性，特别是在辩论设置环节，学生们为团队获胜表现出强烈的动力。
Achievement of Teaching Objectives 教学目标的达成
-
Objective 1 (Third Speaker definition) achieved through initial discussion and video analysis. 目标1（第三发言人定义）通过初步讨论和视频分析得以达成。
-
Objectives 2 & 3 (Practice and Argumentation) fully achieved through the mock debate. 目标2和3（练习和论证）通过模拟辩论得到了充分实现。
5. Subsequent Teaching Suggestions 5. 后续教学建议
Teaching Strengths 教学优势
Identified Strengths: 识别的优势：
-
Expertly modeling the Third Speaker role through the 'Clive' persona, even summarizing/rebutting on the fly. 通过“Clive”角色专业地示范了第三发言人的角色，甚至即兴进行了总结和反驳。
-
Effective management of guest students (Neil and Renee), integrating them seamlessly into the structure. 有效地管理了客座学生（Neil和Renee），将他们无缝地融入到结构中。
Effective Methods: 有效方法：
-
Using a prior video example to solidify abstract concepts before practice. 使用先前的视频示例在练习前固化抽象概念。
-
The competitive team structure (Boys vs. Girls) provided high intrinsic motivation for participation. 竞争性的团队结构（男生对女生）为参与提供了很高的内在动力。
Positive Feedback: 正面反馈：
-
The teacher highly praised Clara's detailed analysis of the video example, noting significant growth in her analytical skills. 老师高度赞扬了Clara对视频示例的详细分析，并指出她的分析能力有了显著的提升。
Next Teaching Focus 下一步教学重点
-
Continuing role-specific practice, potentially focusing on the First and Second Speakers for the next session. 继续进行角色专项练习，下一节课可能重点关注第一和第二发言人。
-
Further development of rebuttal techniques and managing cross-team questioning. 进一步发展反驳技巧并管理跨团队提问环节。
Specific Suggestions for Student's Needs 针对学生需求的具体建议
Pronunciation & Reading: 发音与阅读：
-
Neil should focus on slightly projecting his voice, especially towards the end of his speaking turns, to ensure clarity throughout the three minutes. Neil应专注于稍微提高音量，特别是在发言结束时，以确保三分钟内声音清晰可闻。
Speaking & Communication: 口语与交流：
-
Mason should practice clearly signposting his three distinct reasons before elaborating on each one to improve argument flow. Mason应该练习在阐述三个不同论点之前清晰地标明它们，以改善论证流程。
-
All speakers should consciously use transition phrases like 'In conclusion,' or 'To summarize,' especially when acting as the Third Speaker (or summarizing for the team). 所有发言人都应有意识地使用过渡短语，如‘总而言之’或‘总结来说’，尤其是在扮演第三发言人（或为团队总结）时。
Debating Technique: 辩论技巧：
-
When rebutting, explicitly name the speaker or team you are addressing (e.g., 'Speaker Mason stated...', rather than just making a general statement). 反驳时，应明确指出你正在反驳的发言人或团队（例如，‘Mason发言人提到...’，而不是只做一般性陈述。）
Recommended Supplementary Learning Resources or Homework 推荐的补充学习资源或家庭作业
-
Research 3 examples of non-mainstream sports athletes (like Netball or Diving) and calculate what percentage of the average UK salary their earnings represent to prepare evidence for the next debate. 研究3个非主流运动项目运动员的例子（如无板篮球或跳水），并计算他们的收入占英国平均工资的百分比，为下一次辩论准备证据。