Bridging British Education Virtual Academy 伦桥国际教育
1v1 English Lesson - Debate Role Practice (Third Speaker Focus) 1v1 英语课程 - 辩论角色练习（侧重第三发言人）
1. Course Basic Information 1. 课程基本信息
Teaching Focus 教学重点
Mastering the role of the Third Speaker in a debate: summarizing team arguments, rebutting the opposition, and reinforcing key points without introducing new evidence.
掌握辩论中第三发言人的角色：总结本方论点、反驳对方观点，并在不引入新论据的情况下加强关键信息。
Teaching Objectives 教学目标
-
Understand the specific duties and required tone of a debate's third speaker. 理解辩论中第三发言人的具体职责和所需语调（必须听起来像已经赢了）。
-
Practice rebutting the opposition's main points from the perspective of the third speaker. 练习从第三发言人的角度反驳对方的主要论点。
-
Practice reinforcing and restating the team's core arguments using different wording. 练习用不同的措辞来加强和重申本方的核心论点。
2. Course Content Overview 2. 课程内容概览
Main Teaching Activities and Time Allocation 主要教学活动和时间分配
Warm-up & Personal Check-in: Teacher checked in with George about his holiday (skiing/snowboarding in Beijing) and Christmas presents.
热身与个人问候： 老师与George就他的假期（在北京滑雪/单板滑雪）和圣诞礼物进行了交流。
Introduction to Third Speaker Role: Detailed explanation of the third speaker's role: summarizing, rebutting, sounding victorious, and not introducing new arguments.
第三发言人角色介绍： 详细解释第三发言人的角色：总结、反驳、展现胜利姿态，并且不引入新论据。
Practice Rebuttal: Homework Debate: George practiced rebutting previous arguments in the 'Homework Should Be Banned' motion from the third negative speaker's perspective.
反驳练习：家庭作业辩论： George以第三反方发言人的身份，练习反驳“应禁止家庭作业”辩题中已有的论点。
Teacher Input & Role Clarification: Teacher emphasized reinforcing team points without direct copying and reviewed preparation strategy for the third speaker.
教师输入与角色澄清： 老师强调了在不完全抄袭的情况下重申团队观点，并回顾了第三发言人的准备策略。
Debate Simulation: Cars in City Centers: Students prepared and delivered speeches for Speaker 1 (Affirmative: Anne, Negative: George), Speaker 2 (Rebuttal), and Speaker 3 (Final Summary).
辩论模拟：城市中心禁车： 学生准备并进行了第一发言人（正方：Anne，反方：George）、第二发言人（反驳）和第三发言人（最终总结）的演说。
Wrap-up and Preference Discussion: Teacher assessed the performance as a draw and discussed with students which debate role (1st, 2nd, or 3rd speaker) they preferred and why.
总结与角色偏好讨论： 老师判定本次表现为平局，并与学生讨论了他们更喜欢哪个辩论角色（一、二、三发言人）以及原因。
Language Knowledge and Skills 语言知识与技能
rebuttal, reinforce, summary, judge, motion, congestion charge, pollution, fume, independent, unreliable, practically, terrific, ingenious
反驳, 加强/重申, 总结, 裁判/评委, 动议/议题, 拥堵费, 污染, 烟雾, 独立地, 不可靠的, 实际上, 了不起的, 巧妙的/绝妙的
The structure and strategy of the Third Speaker in a formal debate.
正式辩论中第三发言人的结构和策略。
Public speaking, persuasive argumentation, active listening (for rebuttal), summarizing complex ideas concisely, maintaining an assertive tone.
公开演讲、有说服力的论证、积极倾听（用于反驳）、简洁地总结复杂观点、保持自信的语调。
Teaching Resources and Materials 教学资源与材料
-
Pre-recorded teacher opinions on the topic 'Should cars be banned in large cities?' 关于“是否应禁止汽车进入大城市？”主题的预先录制的教师观点。
-
Debate structure guidance (First, Second, Third Speaker roles) 辩论结构指南（第一、第二、第三发言人角色）
3. Student Performance Assessment (George (and Anne participated)) 3. 学生表现评估 (George (and Anne participated))
Participation and Activeness 参与度和积极性
-
Very high engagement; George and Anne actively took on all three roles (Speaker 1, 2, and 3) in the simulation. 参与度非常高；George和Anne在模拟中积极承担了所有三个角色（第一、第二和第三发言人）。
Language Comprehension and Mastery 语言理解和掌握
-
High comprehension of the third speaker's duties, particularly the need to reinforce team points rather than introduce new ones. 对第三发言人职责的理解很高，特别是理解了需要重申团队观点而非引入新论点。
Language Output Ability 语言输出能力
Oral: 口语：
-
George demonstrated strong fluency when delivering the prepared first speech; the rebuttal sections required quicker thinking. George在发表准备好的第一篇演讲时展示了很强的流利度；反驳环节则要求更快的反应速度。
Written: 书面：
N/A (Preparation notes were made verbally/briefly during the allotted time).
不适用（准备笔记是在分配时间内口头/简要完成的）。
Student's Strengths 学生的优势
-
George strongly prefers the first speaker role, where he can prepare his speech fully, leading to high fluency. George非常喜欢第一发言人的角色，因为他可以充分准备演讲，表现出高流利度。
-
Anne demonstrated a good grasp of summarizing her points clearly during her third speaker address. Anne在她的第三发言人演讲中，清晰总结自身观点的能力表现出色。
-
Both students successfully managed the mental shift required to switch between the three distinct speaker roles. 两位学生成功地完成了在三个不同发言人角色之间切换所需的思维转变。
Areas for Improvement 需要改进的方面
-
George needs practice in spontaneous rebuttal delivery, as he expressed a clear preference for prepared material (Speaker 1). George需要练习即兴反驳的表达，因为他明确表示更喜欢准备好的材料（第一发言人）。
-
Both students need to develop stronger techniques for restating team arguments in a fresh way as the third speaker, rather than sounding too repetitive. 两位学生需要发展更强有力的技巧，在作为第三发言人时以新颖的方式重申团队论点，避免听起来过于重复。
4. Teaching Reflection 4. 教学反思
Effectiveness of Teaching Methods 教学方法的有效性
-
High effectiveness in explaining and modeling the third speaker role through immediate, active practice. 通过即时、主动的练习，有效地解释和示范了第三发言人的角色。
-
The debate simulation, despite being only two participants, was highly beneficial for understanding role transitions. 尽管只有两名参与者，但辩论模拟对于理解角色转换非常有益。
Teaching Pace and Time Management 教学节奏和时间管理
-
The pace was well-managed, allowing significant time for explanation, practice drills, and the full three-part debate simulation. 课程节奏管理得当，为解释、练习和完整的三部分辩论模拟留出了充足的时间。
Classroom Interaction and Atmosphere 课堂互动和氛围
Positive, encouraging, and highly interactive. The teacher provided immediate positive reinforcement, even when students found role-switching difficult.
积极、鼓励性强且互动性高。老师提供了即时的积极强化，即使学生在角色转换中遇到困难也是如此。
Achievement of Teaching Objectives 教学目标的达成
-
Objectives regarding understanding the third speaker role were achieved through direct application. 通过直接应用，关于理解第三发言人角色的目标已达成。
-
Students gained practical experience in delivering all three debate segments. 学生获得了完成辩论所有三个环节的实践经验。
5. Subsequent Teaching Suggestions 5. 后续教学建议
Teaching Strengths 教学优势
Identified Strengths: 识别的优势：
-
Excellent use of immediate application (role-play) to teach abstract concepts (debate structure). 出色地利用即时应用（角色扮演）来教授抽象概念（辩论结构）。
-
Skillfully managed the complexity of having two students cover three roles each. 高超地管理了让两名学生分别扮演三个角色的复杂性。
Effective Methods: 有效方法：
-
Breaking down the third speaker's task into clear components: rebuttal + reinforcement. 将第三发言人的任务分解为清晰的组成部分：反驳 + 加强。
-
Asking students about their preferred roles to gauge comfort level and identify areas for targeted practice. 询问学生更喜欢的角色，以评估舒适度并确定有针对性的练习领域。
Positive Feedback: 正面反馈：
-
George's fluency in his prepared first speech was 'perfect'. George准备好的第一篇演讲流利度被评价为“完美”。
-
The conclusion of the session where the teacher declared the debate a '100% draw' was highly encouraging. 课程总结时，老师宣布辩论“100%平局”的环节极大地鼓励了学生。
Next Teaching Focus 下一步教学重点
-
Debate Role Practice: Focus on the First Speaker's preparation and delivery, using the next topic: 'Should every child have to join a sports team?' 辩论角色练习：侧重第一发言人的准备和表达，使用下一个主题：“是否每个孩子都必须加入运动队？”
Specific Suggestions for Student's Needs 针对学生需求的具体建议
Pronunciation & Reading: 发音与阅读：
-
Continue working on pace control during spontaneous speaking (Speaker 2/3) to maintain clarity when thinking quickly. 继续关注快速思考时的语速控制，以在即兴发言（第二/三发言人）时保持清晰度。
Speaking & Communication: 口语与交流：
-
For the third speaker: Practice using stronger synonyms or metaphors when reiterating a teammate's point to ensure it sounds fresh, not copied. 对于第三发言人：练习使用更强有力的同义词或比喻来重申队友的观点，确保听起来新颖而不是照抄。
-
George: Focus on building confidence in the rebuttal role (Speaker 2) as this is critical for debate success. George：专注于建立在反驳角色（第二发言人）中的信心，这对辩论的成功至关重要。
Recommended Supplementary Learning Resources or Homework 推荐的补充学习资源或家庭作业
-
Review notes on the techniques for reinforcing arguments as a third speaker. 复习作为第三发言人加强论点的技巧笔记。